Requirements
What are the requirements for a lawful arrest?
In Bulgaria, the grounds and procedure for arrest are explained in the Ministry of Interior Act. But it is also important that the police are not using these grounds in the wrong way. For example, if the police know that you did not commit an offence, but they still want to ‘fish’ for information and therefore arrest you.
Requirements
To evaluate whether your arrest may violate your human rights, namely, your right to liberty and security, you should pay attention to the following requirements:
- The arrest must correspond to the grounds prescribed in the Ministry of Interior Act
- The police must have a reasonable suspicion that you have committed an offence. Reasonable suspicion means that the police already have information that would satisfy an objective observer that you may have committed an offence. An objective observer is, for instance, someone who is not related to you and not interested in protecting you
- The arrest must be carried out according to the procedure prescribed in the Ministry of Interior Act
- The police or other appropriate authorities must have the intention to try you for the suspected offence. If they do not have such an intention, they must not arrest you.
- The arrest order or protocol has to clearly state which ground for arrest is being applied in your case and why. It must contain both statement of the relevant provisions of the law, as well as a description of the relevant facts on the basis of which you are suspected of having committed an offense.
- The police or other authorities must not trick you into surrendering. For example, they cannot invite you to come to the police station for another reason and then arrest you for an offence.
- The arrest has to be truly necessary in the specific circumstances of the case. For example, if someone has been caught exactly at the moment of stealing a mobile phone from a shop and this person would run away if not arrested and would later be impossible to find.
- You must be held in a place that is meant for persons arrested on criminal suspicion. In Bulgaria, you should be held in specially equipped police premises specifically designed for holding arrested persons and corresponding to the relevant standards
Resources
Law
4
Constitution of the Republic of Bulgaria
In force as of 13 July 1991
Article 30
Article 30
European Convention on Human Rights
In force for Bulgaria as of 7 September 1992
Article 5 (1) c)
Article 5 (1) c)
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
In force for Bulgaria as of 23 March 1976
Article 9
Article 9
Law on the Ministry of Interior
In force as of 27 June 2014
Articles 72, 73, 74, 75
Articles 72, 73, 74, 75
Case Law
5
A. and Others v. the United Kingdom
European Court of Human Rights
19 February 2009
19 February 2009
Fox, Campbell and Hartley v. the United Kingdom
European Court of Human Rights
30 August 1990
30 August 1990
Other
1
General comment No 35: Article 9 (Liberty and security of person)
UN Human Rights Committee
16 December 2014
16 December 2014
Human Rights Guide
A European platform for human rights education